Environmental Protection Blog

Blog archive

Pesticides Linked to ADHD in Children

While the debate over whether to eat organic wages on, a study released yesterday provides some of the first hard evidence that pesticides affect the health of everyday consumers of conventionally grown produce.

A study published in the journal Pediatrics found that children who had significantly higher levels of a breakdown product of a certain kind of pesticide in their urine were twice as likely to be diagnosed with attention-deficit-hyperactivity disorder. Some 119 children from the 1,140-child sample were diagnosed with the disorder.

This is significant because previous research into the links between pesticide use and human health had focused on those who were constantly exposed to these pesticides, such as farmers or others who work in the fields.

The particular class of pesticide tested, neurotoxic organophosphates, can be found in many food, including frozen blueberries, strawberries and celery. Kind of scary, isn’t it?

Many supporters of conventionally grown food emphasize that it’s the dose of these chemicals that matters, not their presence. That is, if a pesticide causes cancer at an exposure level of 1 mg consumed per week, the fact that that .000001 mg of the chemical makes it onto a piece of fruit doesn’t mean that someone who eats that fruit will get cancer.

But this study significantly undercuts that assertion, as the children who were diagnosed with ADHD were consuming these supposedly harmless amounts of pesticides with their carrots and peas. Kind of scary, isn’t it?

Eating a diet with only organic fruits and vegetables is a surefire way to avoid consuming these pesticides, though that’s not always possible. Many people (including me) can’t afford to buy only organic produce. But you can shop strategically, choosing organic for produce that typically gets treated with a great deal of pesticide. You can use the Environmental Working Group’s “Dirty Dozen” as a guide, though it has come under some criticism for its methodology. You can also try farmers’ markets, which often have lower prices because they cut out the middleman of the grocery store. Local Harvest has a great database that lets you search by location for farmers’ markets, local farms and food co-ops that could get you a better deal on organic produce.

We’re just starting to learn about whether pesticides actually present a danger to those who consume conventionally grown foods. Like most problems, it’s one with nuance that most interest groups fail to capture. So while this study doesn’t mean that all conventional produce will cause health problems for you and your family, it does mean we need to keep researching the effects of these chemicals and consider buying organic produce when possible.

Posted by Laura Williams on Sep 13, 2011 at 12:00 AM


Comments

Mon, Sep 26, 2011

@Jim (New Mexico). The article actually says 119/1,140 which would be just over 10%.

Thu, Sep 22, 2011

The last actual "study" I saw on this matter was a very poorly designed survey, not a controlled study, done in the San Joaquin Valley in which Mexican immigrants' who had been tested for OP/carbamate residues, were then phone interviewed about whether they thought their children had ADHD. This "study" has been restated in numerous journals and public press as conclusive evidence of a link. My psychology colleagues have expressed extreme doubt about all of these studies, since the causes of ADHD are so poorly understood at this time. Who is to say that these symptoms are not associated with other dynamics present in this particular demographic. Before we can go pointing fingers, carefully CONTROLLED studies must be done. It was decades before all the ills from coffee were eventually shown to be the effects of smoking. Seems heavy coffee drinkers were often smokers. Who knew?

Wed, Sep 21, 2011 Jim New Mexico

Wow! 119 of 140 kids were diagnosed with ADHD! That is 85%! On average, what is the percentage of children that normally have ADHD? I would like to see the data from this test to see if it is valid. Many of the articles I have read recently from Enviromental Protection seem to be questionable at best. Just writers pushing for sensationalism; don't let the facts get in ht way.

Wed, Sep 21, 2011 Roger

From my observations most people won't purchase truly organic produce because of the cosmetics of insect and disease damage, it doesn't look pretty. Are they sure the pesticides and chemicals are sprayed on the produce or is it in the tap water they are washed in.

Tue, Sep 20, 2011 SantoDe

Neurotoxins? How ’bout yet another excuse for bad behavior and rotten parenting. Yes, catigate me if you will. But ADHD became a buzzword in the 1970s, around the same time our entire style of raising kids in stable, atomic, households went to pot. We descended into a nation of 2-income couples, heavy day-care use, and steep rises in the divorce rate. And whaddya know? We started making excuses for children with poor attention span, bad behavior, and poor school performance.

Sorry. When somebody can truly separate ADHD out from what is just plain ol’ bad behavior brought on by lack of attention and discipline, let me know. Until then, it’s a crock.

Tue, Sep 20, 2011 Laura Williams

Hi Jeff -- I'm sorry about that. Some of the code got mixed up, rendering the links inactive. It should be fixed now.

Tue, Sep 20, 2011 Jeff

Wow! This is quite the accusation. Maybe some working links to this research would be helpful.

Thu, Sep 15, 2011 Jeff

It is good to eat as much organic fruit and veggies as possible, but they are not 100% free of pesticdes and chemicals. There are certain chemicals and pesticdes that are permitted to be used on orgainc fruit and veggies. This does reduce the risk as they are far less harmful. We should also wash them with a 100% chemical free and organic fruit and veggie wash as water alone does not ensure that you have removed all the bacteria and chemicals from fruit and veggies.

Add your Comment

Your Name:(optional)
Your Email:(optional)
Your Location:(optional)
Comment:
Please type the letters/numbers you see above