American Vanguard Files Suit for Relief from EPA Stop Sale Order
American Vanguard Corporation has filed an action against the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia on Aug. 27 seeking emergency and injunctive relief from a Stop Sale, Use or Removal Order recently issued relating to the company’s EPA-registered pentachloronitrobenzene (PCNB) product line.
The company’s wholly-owned subsidiary, Amvac Chemical Corporation, manufactures, distributes and sells PCNB as a fungicide for use primarily on turf with the bulk of sales occurring in September and October.
The agency issued the stop sale order on the ground that it thought the company did not identify trace impurities in the product in a submission to the agency called a confidential statement of formula (CSF). The company believes that the stop sale order is without merit and that, in fact, the agency has known about these impurities for nearly 20 years and has never made a determination that these impurities (which the agency now claims could be of toxicological significance) had to be identified on the CSF.
The order does not allege that the presence of these impurities creates any risk to human health or the environment. The company hopes to work through these technical issues with the agency as it has on other issues in the past, but does not believe the law allows the agency to stop sales of this approved product before due process has been afforded the company.
Eric Wintemute, president and chief executive officer, said, “We were surprised and disappointed to have received this order without advance warning just as our main selling season is starting. We believe that the order has no defensible legal basis and have been working without success with the agency to try to effect an informal resolution. However, at this point, we have no choice but to take legal action in order to protect our business.” Wintemute added, “We appreciate our customers’ continued support as we work through this issue with the agency.” The company expects to receive a ruling from the court on its motion for a temporary restraining order within the week and will report on that ruling when received. "